Evaluating Sources [Activity]

Kimberly Stelly

Directions

Use an article* and the internet to answer the following questions. Doing so will help determine if the article is a reliable source.

*Note to the instructor: Model with an example article published in the last year.

 

Learning Outcomes

Upon successful completion of this activity, students will

  • evaluate the reliability of a source by assessing the credibility and objectivity of its author, research methods and sources, publishing source and date, and more.

Questions of Reliability

  1. Who wrote the article? Is the author an authority or expert on the topic they have written about? Is the author connected with a well-known source? How does this person establish ethos (credibility)?
  2. Who is this article written for? Who is the specific audience? Is it the general public? How do you know? What is the author’s purpose: to persuade, inform, entertain, etc.?
  3. What kind of research did the author do to write this article? Look for references to other entities.  Does the author refer to a specific person or group of people? Identify these sources. Are the sources cited? Are links provided? Double-check the author’s sources. Are those sources reliable? How do you know?
  4. How objective is your author? Are they fair or biased? Include specific textual evidence to convey the author’s bias.
  5. What is the date of the publication? Identify the publication information. Is the publication well-known?  Explain why this publication should or should not be trusted.
  6. What is your overall impression or evaluation of the article? Is this a reliable source? Is the information credible? Explain your answers.
  7. Explain why and how you would or would not use this article.

Downloadable Resources (Activity)

''''

 

Click here to download a Word doc of this activity:

Evaluating Sources activity

 

 

Attribution:

Stelly, Kimberly. “Evaluating Sources [Activity].” Strategies, Skills and Models for Student Success in Writing and Reading Comprehension. College Station: Texas A&M University, 2024. This work is licensed with a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Evaluating Sources [Activity] Copyright © by Kimberly Stelly is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.